Blog

Before You Swap Your FD for an NCD, Remember 2018

FD-NCD

Before You Swap Your FD for an NCD, Remember 2018

In September 2018, IL&FS began defaulting on its debt. Many investors had treated the group as too important to fail. Its rating was top-grade until shortly before the defaults. Less than a year later, DHFL defaulted as well, and ordinary investors held its publicly issued debentures.

That history is worth keeping in mind whenever a debenture is described simply as “better than an FD.” The search for alternatives to fixed deposits is reasonable. But the two options people most often consider carry quite different risks.

State Government bonds, also called State Development Loans, are issued by state governments and auctioned through the Reserve Bank of India. They typically yield a little more than central government securities. Individuals can buy them through RBI Retail Direct or on stock exchanges. Default risk is generally considered very low. Price risk is not. If rates rise and the bond is sold before maturity, the investor can lose money on it.

Secured NCDs, or non-convertible debentures, are issued by companies and backed by a charge on specific assets. “Secured” sounds reassuring, but it only means there is something to claim if the company fails. Recovering money through that claim can take years. Credit ratings help, though 2018 showed how fast they can drop. Many NCDs are listed but thinly traded, so selling early may mean accepting a poor price.

Tax narrows the gap more than people expect. Interest from both options is taxed at the investor’s slab rate, the same as FD interest. The real gain is only the extra yield, measured against the extra risk.

Ashutosh Financial Services tends to judge these instruments by portfolio construction rather than headline rates. That means limiting exposure to any single issuer, matching maturities to when the money is actually needed, and treating an unusually high coupon as a question to investigate. CA Rajit Kothari’s recent video on these instruments covers how they fit into a diversified portfolio.

Helping investors ask the right questions before they buy is a large part of the education work Ashutosh Financial Services continues to do.