Most investors agree a portfolio should be reviewed. Far fewer agree on what a review actually is. Three assumptions cause most of the confusion.
Myth: a review means switching funds.
Reality: a good review often ends with very little change. Exiting a fund can bring an exit load and capital gains tax, and moving to last year’s top performer rarely pays off. If a review always produces a list of trades, it probably wasn’t done carefully.
Myth: one year’s returns show whether a fund is working.
Reality: a fund should be compared with its own benchmark and category over a full market cycle, not over twelve months. SEBI’s 2017 rules on categorising schemes made this easier, because funds within a category are now meant to follow similar mandates. The more useful test is style drift. If a “large-cap” fund keeps adding smaller companies, the investor holds something different from what they chose.
Myth: more funds means more diversification.
Reality: overlap is common. Five equity funds can end up holding many of the same large companies. The investor pays five sets of costs and gets something close to one portfolio.
So what should a review check? First, whether the mix of equity and debt has drifted away from the plan after a strong or weak year. Second, whether the goals have changed. Money for a child’s university fees that is now three years away shouldn’t stay fully in equity. Third, whether the fund manager has changed, and how much the investor is paying in expense ratios.
The reviews Ashutosh Financial Services conducts generally start with goals and timelines, and only then look at individual funds. That order matters, because a fund can be perfectly good and still be wrong for the job it’s been given. Once a year is usually enough, along with a check after any major life event. CA Rajit Kothari explains the reasoning in more detail in a recent video.
Through explainers like that one, Ashutosh Financial Services aims to show investors that a portfolio review is about discipline, not activity.


